There are 505 listings for rare pennies... not finding what you are looking for? Search 1880-1909 for even more...
Register for News & Special Offers
Name (optional)

Email

We value your privacy!
current specials
1-25 of 505 rare pennies listings found
page 1/21 Next>
WHEAT PENNY& IH's SHOWING 1876 RARE FL IH AND IH
WHEAT PENNY& IH's SHOWING 1876 RARE FL IH AND IH
View Item
Price:
$10.49
1943 Steel War Penny Rare & Uncirculated
1943 Steel War Penny Rare & Uncirculated
View Item
Price:
$4.99
1918 S Rare Date Lincoln Wheat Penny Cent XF Extra Fine
1918 S Rare Date Lincoln Wheat Penny Cent XF Extra Fine
View Item
Price:
$0.99
2000 MVP Prosign Anfernee Penny Hardaway Autograph Rare
2000 MVP Prosign Anfernee Penny Hardaway Autograph Rare
View Item
Price:
$17.49
1981 Vintage LINCOLN PENNY - RARE NICE SHINY COIN
1981 Vintage LINCOLN PENNY - RARE NICE SHINY COIN
View Item
Price:
$0.75
1910 S LINCOLN HEAD CENT - PENNY RARE - KEY DATE COIN
1910 S LINCOLN HEAD CENT - PENNY RARE - KEY DATE COIN
View Item
Price:
$3.24
1962 Vintage LINCOLN PENNY - RARE NICE SHINY COIN!
1962 Vintage LINCOLN PENNY - RARE NICE SHINY COIN!
View Item
Price:
$0.75
RARE 1862 indian head penny A VERY NICE COIN
RARE 1862 indian head penny A VERY NICE COIN
View Item
Price:
$0.99
1864 INDIAN HEAD CENT PENNY RARE KEY COIN
1864 INDIAN HEAD CENT PENNY RARE KEY COIN
View Item
Price:
$0.99
1931-S LINCOLN WHEAT PENNY **RARE** GEM UNCIRCULATED
1931-S LINCOLN WHEAT PENNY **RARE** GEM UNCIRCULATED
View Item
Price:
$99.95
RARE 2006 Illinois Geocoin - Copper Penny Look
RARE 2006 Illinois Geocoin - Copper Penny Look
View Item
Price:
$0.99
Rare 1956 D Lincoln Wheat Penny One Cent Error
Rare 1956 D Lincoln Wheat Penny One Cent Error
View Item
Price:
$1.50
1834 PENNY MAGAZINE RARE 3RD ED. SDUK STONEHENGE RIALTO
1834 PENNY MAGAZINE RARE 3RD ED. SDUK STONEHENGE RIALTO
View Item
Price:
$59.99
*RARE* 1931-S Lincoln Cent Penny PCGS graded XF-45
*RARE* 1931-S Lincoln Cent Penny PCGS graded XF-45
View Item
Price:
$100.00
1867 Key Date INDIAN HEAD CENT PENNY * rare usa coin
1867 Key Date INDIAN HEAD CENT PENNY * rare usa coin
View Item
Price:
$6.05
OLD CANADIAN COINS RARE 1871 PENNY CANADA CENT SHARP 1
OLD CANADIAN COINS RARE 1871 PENNY CANADA CENT SHARP 1
View Item
Price:
$2.67
1953 D DAVIDSON'S AMBRIDGE PA ENCASED WHEAT PENNY RARE
1953 D DAVIDSON'S AMBRIDGE PA ENCASED WHEAT PENNY RARE
View Item
Price:
$0.99
1862 UK ENGLAND LARGE PENNY rare [B3]
1862 UK ENGLAND LARGE PENNY rare [B3]
View Item
Price:
$0.99
1900 BIG PENNY CANADA RARE
Recent Listing: 2008-12-03T22:29:00.000Z
1900 BIG PENNY CANADA RARE
View Item
Price:
$3.99
2006 HOLIDAY GIFT SET - 0 25 $ COLOR SANTA AND RUDOLPH
Recent Listing: 2008-12-04T02:20:00.000Z
2006 HOLIDAY GIFT SET - 0 25 $ COLOR SANTA AND RUDOLPH
View Item
Price:
$13.58
Rare PENNY (BLONDIE) SINGLETON Arcade Exhibit Card 40's
Recent Listing: 2008-12-04T04:32:03.000Z
Rare PENNY (BLONDIE) SINGLETON Arcade Exhibit Card 40's
View Item
Price:
$3.99
Rare 1916I Proof MULE half penny - Quality Replica .
Rare 1916I Proof MULE half penny - Quality Replica .
View Item
Price:
AU $19.95
($12.93)
RARE 1 OZ .999 COPPER JUMBO 2009 PENNY BAR COIN BULLION
Recent Listing: 2008-12-04T17:01:00.000Z
RARE 1 OZ .999 COPPER JUMBO 2009 PENNY BAR COIN BULLION
View Item
Price:
$0.01
1959 UNCIRCULATED PENNY: Jack Nicklaus card Golf Rare
1959 UNCIRCULATED PENNY: Jack Nicklaus card Golf Rare
View Item
Price:
$79.95
NIKE AIR MAX PENNY Black-Silver-White RARE! 2 II sz 15
NIKE AIR MAX PENNY Black-Silver-White RARE! 2 II sz 15
View Item
Price:
$95.00